MALACCA:
The culling of almost 100,000 long-tailed macaques last year by the
Wildlife and National Parks Department (Perhilitan) has turned into a
controversy, with the decision being challenged here.
Kota Melaka MCA complaint bureau deputy chief
Dr Yee Kok Wah
said he found out that Johor topped the list with 20,600 of the
primates culled, followed by Selangor (18,800), Perak (16,000), Kedah
(13,000), Pahang (8,100) and Negri Sembilan (8,000).
The total number culled last year was 97,200, up from 87,900 in 2011.
“The primates should not have been exterminated as they were not diseased.
“We need to create a colony for them so that the monkeys can be relocated.
“We have a moral responsibility to look after the primates.
“They will not pose a danger to humans if they are relocated to the jungle,'' he told
The Star.
Dr
Yee said Kyoto University's Juichi Yamagiwa, who is president of the
International Primatological Society, had found that the transmission of
virus between humans and macaques was very rare.
“As such, the mass culling of macaques here should be stopped.
“The primates are being driven to extinction,'' he added.
Dr
Yee said there was a report saying that captured wild macaques from
Malaysia had ended up on dinner plates in China, Taiwan, South Korea and
Japan, or in research laboratories.
Long-tailed macaques are native to Malaysia and considered opportunistic feeders, and can adapt well to the urban environment.
A
Perhilitan official, when contacted, explained that the primates were
exterminated through an internationally accepted culling method to
control “a population that far exceeded the proportionate capacity of
its habitat”.
He said the culling, conducted by trained game rangers, was carried out where human-macaque conflicts were most serious.
He
denied that the macaques were killed by deliberate drowning as alleged
by some quarters, adding that standard operating procedures were adhered
to.
Tuesday March 19, 2013
There’s no need to cull macaques, says expert
PETALING JAYA: Culling is not the answer to resolving human-macaque conflicts in Malaysia, said an expert.
Wildlife veterinarian
Dr Sharmini Paramasivam said humans had invaded the monkeys’ habitat.
“Studies have shown that effective waste management and sterilisation reduces the size of the population.”
The wildlife veterinarian said it was unfair to blame monkeys for going into housing areas and rummaging through rubbish bins.
“We should first look at how residential areas are being planned.”
The Star reported
yesterday that almost 100,000 long-tailed macaques had been culled last
year by the Department of Wildlife and National Parks (Perhilitan).
A
Perhilitan official had explained that the primates were exterminated
through an internationally-accepted culling method to control their
population, which “far exceeded the proportionate capacity of its
habitat”. He said culling had been carried out where human-macaque
conflicts were most serious.
Dr Sharmini was involved in running a
macaque conflict management project in Indonesia and has worked with
the monkeys for a few years.
She said conflict management
included studying the macaque population and their behavioural patterns,
as well as conducting education programmes for those living in conflict
areas.
“Malaysia should set an example on the best way to deal
with wildlife conflict. Understanding the cause of the conflict is key
in successful conflict management,” she stressed.
Wednesday March 20, 2013
Decision to cull macaques not done in haste
WE refer to the reports “
Uproar over macaques culling” and “
There’s no need to cull macaques, says expert” (
The Star, March 18 and March 19) respectively.
We
at the Department of Wildlife and National Parks (Perhilitan) feel very
sad that such articles were published as the journalist was informed
and explanations given on the culling of macaques by this department.
We
would like to stress that the government decision to cull the excess
population of macaques in peninsular Malaysia was not done in haste.
The estimated population of the long-tailed macaques (
Macaca fascicularis) in peninsular Malaysia is estimated at 740,000 heads and well distributed in the urban areas in peninsular Malaysia.
The long-tailed macaque is a pest species and can easily adapt to any urban habitat.
It
is prolific and able to reproduce very fast. There is no question of
the species being threatened into extinction with culling.
The long-tailed macaque has the third largest range of any primate species, after humans and the rhesus macaque.
The culling practice was discussed in detail with NGOs, experts and scientists.
This
department had been actively involved in the dialogues and engagement
with all stakeholders on the culling practice before it was implemented.
The
disturbance caused by the long-tailed macaque has undermined the
tolerance level of the communities to co-exist with them.
The culling exercise has nothing to do with diseases carried by this species.
Nevertheless,
the department has intensively collaborated with scientists from both
local and foreign universities to screen for known and unknown diseases
which long-tailed macaques might spread as potential carriers/hosts.
To
date, there are several pathogena found in the primate such as
plasmodium sp., herpes virus, Filovirus, Flavivirus and Paramyxcovirus.
Relocation
of problem long-tailed macaques to forested areas in the long term is
just a temporary transfer of the problem when a new conflict will be
created as long-tailed macaques are territorial.
The department
disputes the allegation that the culling practise will push the
long-tailed macaque into extinction as this is not true.
We are
only culling the problematic population in urban and sub-urban areas and
not the macaques’ population that live in protected forests.
In fact, IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2012 categorised the long-tailed macaques as “Least Concern”.
If
one looks closely at the statistics published in the department’s
annual report, one can see that the complaints on human-macaque conflict
received by this department from 2007 to 2012 was 40,407 cases with
10,232 cases in 2008 and 3,235 in 2012.
Just imagine, with the
culling of 87,819 heads in 2011, we still had 4,913 complaints. With
the culling of 97,119 heads last year, the complaints still stood at
3,235 cases.
We would like to disassociate ourselves with the
allegation that the “captured wild macaques from Malaysia had ended up
on dinner plates in China, Taiwan, South Korea and Japan, or in research
laboratories” as claimed by Dr Yee Kok Wah of the Kota Melaka MCA
Complaints Bureau. This is a very serious allegation.
We would like to state that we stopped the exporting of long-tailed macaques for commercial purpose from 1986.
The
wildlife management toll employed is an anthropocentric approach as the
management and practices undertaken are to solve the problems of
communities and human well-being.
Wildlife is well protected in the protected areas system throughout peninsular Malaysia.
Last
but not least, we always welcome constructive feedback and real
cooperation from interested parties in dealing with the human-macaque
conflict.
DIRECTOR GENERAL
Department of Wildlife and National Parks (Perhilitan)
PET+BLOGSPOT is the ONLINE BLOG of the Malaysian Animal-Assisted Therapy for the Disabled and Elderly Association or Petpositive.
Our stories are CURRENT, ACCURATE and RELIABLE.
We offer both local and foreign news on animals, disability and the elderly.
PET+BLOGSPOT was first established in October 2007. Our hits since then are now 150,000 and ever increasing!
PET+BLOGSPOT is updated daily.
Kindly note that views expressed in PET+BLOGSPOT are not necessarily those of PETPOSITIVE.
You may also visit our Webpage by browsing: www.petpositive.com.my
You can also find us in Facebook under PETPOSITIVE EMPOWERMENT.
Please sign up as a FOLLOWER of this Blog if you haven't done so already in order to show us your kind support for our work. Thank you!
Submitted by iccha pratita on Saturday, October 30th, 2010.